Top 10 Differences Between Fate: The Winx Saga & Winx Club

To clear up confusion, these are the differences between "Fate: Winx Saga" and "Winx Club." Our countdown includes clipped wings, Riven, Terra Nova, and more! Do YOU prefer "Winx Saga" or "Winx Club?" Let us know in the comments!

Watch more great "Winx" videos here:
Top 10 Cartoon Characters Who Are Totally Fashion Goals -
Top 10 Animated Cartoon Princesses -
Top 10 Saddest TV Cartoon Songs EVER -

Have Your Idea Become A Video!

Subscribe for more great content!

MsMojo is a leading producer of reference online video content of Top 10 Lists, Origins, Biographies, Commentary and more on Pop Culture, Celebrity, Movies, Music, TV, Film, Video Games, Politics, News, Comics, Superheroes. Your trusted authority on ranking Pop Culture.

#Fate #WinxSaga #WinxClub


  1. MsMojo

    MsMojo3 חודשים לפני

    Do YOU prefer "Fate: Winx Saga" or "Winx Club?" Let us know your thoughts below!

  2. joe selzer

    joe selzer16 ימים לפני

    as far as this show not sure if thy will give all the girls wings who are in a group but in the cartoon thy did not have wings at first boom did get her wings first then one by one in the group start to get there wings thy was able to find the magic that give them wings so maybe in the next season thy will

  3. joe selzer

    joe selzer17 ימים לפני

    cartoon winx club way more thy took away the 3 bad girls and put only one thy cut out the wing witch i hat too. thy always doing that with live action not keeping it like the cartoon thy always want to change lots of things if ur going to make a live action from a good cartoon do not change it like Musa does not have the same powers as the cartoon and i though she was Asian in the cartoon not Hispanic so whatever ethnicity they were in the cartoon should be the same in the TV show i guess i feel if u change it you loos what made it grate in the cartoon so yes i prefer the Winx club over the tv live action if this was me making this i would not change any thing the story line of the show would be identical to the cartoon including the script word for word thy would not need to write i new one just get the one thy use for the cartoon so every thing that happen in the cartoon would happen in the live action same story and all

  4. xxBubbleTeaxx

    xxBubbleTeaxx22 ימים לפני

    winx club of course

  5. nicole

    nicoleחודש לפני

    Winx club cuz I like riven and Musa they are my fav couple and also helia and flora

  6. Elena Stanica

    Elena Stanicaחודש לפני

    winx club made more sense, so winx club that be

  7. David Werner

    David Werner7 ימים לפני

    Hol up was that little Yugi and Honda/Tristan Taylor's voices

  8. Cakeland Kim

    Cakeland Kim7 ימים לפני

    I think the darker version is more realistic to showcase if they had copied the cartoon all that sparkle and high spirit energy would have been cringey. Unless their target were 3years olds

  9. Thompson Along

    Thompson Along8 ימים לפני

    I'm so excited for season 2

  10. Robot Kookie

    Robot Kookie9 ימים לפני

    You know what's missing... KIKO!

  11. Ray paul

    Ray paul13 ימים לפני

    This show only need a fashion guider it would be way better

  12. ToukenDanshiWarrior

    ToukenDanshiWarrior19 ימים לפני

    The music video of We Are Believix have characters dressed way better than the casts and extras in the Winx Saga.

  13. Sifilore

    Sifilore20 ימים לפני

    I wanna c all the girls get their wings next season like Bloom did. Roxy any Tecna appear too along with all the girls learn different elements, cause unlike Winx Club, fairies hear can learn all different ones...that's another difference between the 2. I would also guess that Tech fairies like Tecna would b rare as technology isn't a part of nature.

  14. youtube Tv

    youtube Tv26 ימים לפני


  15. youtube Tv

    youtube Tv26 ימים לפני

    Best show ever

  16. Ella

    Ella28 ימים לפני

    You forgot that they completely IGNORED Bloom's royal past

  17. Ella

    Ella28 ימים לפני

    WHAT? You didn't mention Flora, she's the second missing character and a fan favourite of most original fans

  18. Joshua Joshua Gagba

    Joshua Joshua Gagbaחודש לפני

    i also was sad that tecna did not appear but in this series but their powers are based on the nature i do not know what the mind has to do with the nature but technology definetly is not part of the nature but i still hope that her character wil be added maybe as an air fairy like beatrix who is intersted in technology and flora is terras and sams cousin so she is not completly cut out

  19. Meri Stuart

    Meri Stuartחודש לפני

    Number 10: everything

  20. Manana Mokalapa

    Manana Mokalapaחודש לפני

    My favorite will always be the original series. I'm not watching this.

  21. Ausra Marcinkeviciute

    Ausra Marcinkeviciuteחודש לפני

    If you 1) watch more than a couple eps and 2) actually give the show a chance, it's good. Ep 3 was the best one imo if you need a cutoff.

  22. Xj11_ Guy

    Xj11_ Guyחודש לפני

    Here’s what I want RAINBOW to do. I want to.. idk. KNOW WHAT WINX FANS WANTED IN THE FIRST PLACE?

  23. Alicat Gtz

    Alicat Gtzחודש לפני

    I may have an unpopular opinion but I loved this Winx and the fact that it’s for a mature audience. I honestly don’t remember the animated show much so I came to it, looking for similarities but invited everything new it threw out there. I just binged it and am super excited for the second season. I highly recommend it. I’d advise trying not to compare it to the animation as this show seems to be more of a “based off of show” not a total adaptation.

  24. Kgothatso L. Hosie

    Kgothatso L. Hosieחודש לפני

    Winx Club will always be superior.

  25. Ers LF

    Ers LFחודש לפני

    The Winx Saga is a Guilty Pleasure for me, It's look so bad when i remember this is a Live Action of Winx Club but when i see this just as usual Netflix Series and forget that this is a Live Action of Winx Club, it's kinda cool. 6.9/10 from me (It's just my opinion)

  26. Aloha D

    Aloha Dחודש לפני

    All Netflix had to do was EXACTLY remake the animated show but nooooooo... They went all weird and inclusive with it.... Literally not ONE single fairy was even slightly overweight... Terra is... Musa isn't Asian... River and Sky are friends? Where's flora? Why is Stella an UBER bitch? Where's Brandon? Why are NONE of them fashionable? Wth

  27. Ginny Weasley

    Ginny Weasleyחודש לפני

    They are dressed like grandmas in Fate.

  28. Jemima Burton

    Jemima Burtonחודש לפני

    I NEED Riven and Musa to get together next season

  29. ONCE Snowybelle

    ONCE Snowybelleחודש לפני

    Can anyone explain the ending I'm so confused like Rosalind?? Is she good or bad

  30. Wītch.of.the. GłītchX

    Wītch.of.the. GłītchXחודש לפני

    Heres a difference winx club writing is actually good

  31. steven_cos

    steven_cosחודש לפני

    Why couldn't they just combine the live action Musa with the animated version Tecna and Musa like call her Muca or Mica or something like that?? Cuz Musa is an empath in the live action and THE ONLY REASON THEY MADE BRANDON AND SKY SWITCH PLACES WAS SOME BS ANDREAS DIDNT WANNA GET A BODY GUARD FOR SKY

  32. vagosdiamond200

    vagosdiamond200חודש לפני

    Can't find that Winx version with the giant monster half snake and half man and the tyrant with the long hair.. That was the best version and cant find it anywhere..

  33. Megan S

    Megan Sחודש לפני

    The one thing I want to see the most in Fate: The Winx saga is Daphne's story. She's blooms birth sister in the original Winx Club. She has her own great back story, but what's better is that even when she's a Disinbody spirit she still doesn't let anyone or anything stop her from helping her little sister. I love they switch things up in the saga. So, I can't wait to see what they do to bring Daphne into the show.

  34. Bethany Soribada

    Bethany Soribadaחודש לפני

    riven's love interest being beatrix isn't even that different since he was with darcy for a time in the first season of the original series. that didn't really throw me off at all for that reason. the relationship I'm much more concerned about is sky and stella, considering that one comes with a more dramatic personality change and 0 canon basis, unless you could Brandon and sky's identity swap

  35. Bethany Soribada

    Bethany Soribadaחודש לפני

    "we'd love to see them combine their powers" who is this "we" i would actually like to see terra off the show because she shouldn't have been there in the first place. one of the shadiest castings in history. goes along with the meanspirited nature of the show I guess. these producers are seriously the villains. they could have easily made this entirely separate from the wind club original series

  36. Tiffany Dalrymple

    Tiffany Dalrympleחודש לפני

    I’ve never watched the winx club tv show. I know that there’s no wings in the show, are there at least cool transformations? I’ve been considering watching the show, I’d like to know which similarities there are from the winx tv show and the animated cartoon?

  37. Marilla B

    Marilla Bחודש לפני

    I like Fate. I think, having a one on one reenactment of Winx club would be a little cringe. Yes, the characters and story are very different than the original animated series, but I think it's a cool change. And yes, that Stella was a mean girl was a bit of a shock, but her character development just over the first season was great. Can't wait for the second season, though people who hang on to the original to hard won't like it as much probably

  38. Deniz Kara

    Deniz Karaחודש לפני

    Characters, magic skills, relationships, history and even the story! All of them are completely different from the original series. So what's the point? One of the most disappointing changes: No transformation. This is not Winx. This is just an another classic fantasy Netflix series. They should have changed the name too.

  39. divine interventions

    divine interventionsחודש לפני

    I appreciate reality 👍🏼🙌

  40. Isidora Avram

    Isidora Avramחודש לפני

    Honestly I would love to see riven and miss develop a best friend type relationship and then in later seasons it becomes a love story

  41. Isidora Avram

    Isidora Avramחודש לפני


  42. Ruby Hay

    Ruby Hayחודש לפני

    I will more so watch Winx Club over Fate but am looking forward to the second season of Fate.

  43. chuuqie ??

    chuuqie ??חודש לפני

    wait before i watched any videos like this i thought terra was supposted to be flora-

  44. Ruby Hay

    Ruby Hayחודש לפני

    Terra is Flora's cousin in the Fate world.

  45. Intesar Hersi

    Intesar Hersiחודש לפני

    This is weird

  46. Alice Wangari Wachira

    Alice Wangari Wachiraחודש לפני

    This is just Winx club, What if they make a live action Totally Spies! 😰😰😰😨😨😰😓

  47. Alice Wangari Wachira

    Alice Wangari Wachiraחודש לפני

    Flora is my og fav character, if she ain't there, I ain't watching

  48. luchia21100

    luchia21100חודש לפני

    I've watched both and can say that the live action is trash. It would be fine if it weren't advertising itself as Winx for Adults but because it is and how little it gets right is just disrespectful. It easily could've been its own mediocre show without using Winx's name for nostalgia bait. And if anyone says its an "adaptation" not a "remake", adaptations are still supposed to be faithful to the original source material if they are any good. Literally all that's the same here are most of the names of people and places they did not even try to make characters personalities the same and don't get me started on the white washing and character removal. Its a bad show that's just trying to cash in on Winx fans being older now

  49. Kisa Sauer

    Kisa Sauerחודש לפני

    I mean I get that the show was "inspired" by winx but it's still a disappointment. I think if they wouldn't have used the name winx and named the characters after the winx club ones it would have been better. So people wouldn't compare these two shows so much and then it would have really been just inspiration instead of a big flop. (In my opinion) :/

  50. Chunky Freddy

    Chunky Freddyחודש לפני

    Y still don't know why did they remaked a bad show to make it Moré bad

  51. Witches_are_Real

    Witches_are_Realחודש לפני

    I miss tecna the most.😭😭😭

  52. Hellen O.W.

    Hellen O.W.2 חודשים לפני

    Honestly, if you're going to let every little detail bother you, just don't watch. I really enjoyed it and that is all I need to know. That last one really annoyed me by the way. You're not actually telling me that you think the casters are somehow racist, because ''in 2021'' they made different casting decsions than the program they based it off of. You know and this is exactly the point, it is based off the animation, it is not a remake. If you want to see a remake, don't watch and then complain about every change that was made. Personally, I liked this version better than the animation, because I kept an open mind.

  53. FiCiara Aldeweireldt

    FiCiara Aldeweireldt2 חודשים לפני

    Im 9 and i loke Fate winx saga more

  54. lI wormynfrens Il

    lI wormynfrens Il2 חודשים לפני

    UGH! IM SO ANNOYED AT THE NETFLIX ONE! THEY HAVE DIFFERENT PERSONALITIES :( Winx was one of my fav shildhood And no Floara? She is mah fav!

  55. Darth Avatar

    Darth Avatar2 חודשים לפני

    They Whitewashed Musa, Stella is the closest one to Bloom Plus Stella would never be caught wearing black, where are the trix, where is Brandon we don’t want no love triangle, where’s Kiko, where is Musa’s powers

  56. Dayo Badejo

    Dayo Badejo2 חודשים לפני

    I want to see all of them

  57. Luana Vasconcelos

    Luana Vasconcelos2 חודשים לפני

    This is quite a late comment, but I'm reading this text about adaptations and there is a quote that explains why Fate: The Winx Saga doesn't work. Not sure if anyone is going to check this out, but here it is: “While you are altering, your must also remain faithful to two things: the authors intention and emotional core of the original work as it affected you.” (Taken from Goldman, 2009, Adventures in the Screen Trade, p. 324).

  58. Afiya Khan

    Afiya Khan2 חודשים לפני

    Where is Stella that Frank caring girl i only see a girl who is not even a finger nail of her🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

  59. EmeraldFlowerz

    EmeraldFlowerz2 חודשים לפני

    I started watching the animated version because I heard how terrible the live action was...

  60. Caty Herondale

    Caty Herondale2 חודשים לפני

    Is so disappointing that they change practically everything we love as a child watching this show, to be “young adult appropriate” and didn’t even achieved this :) (I also made a video about that :)))

  61. Trevor Simons

    Trevor Simons2 חודשים לפני

    Even the english Rai version of the cartoon is better than the live action netflex show.

  62. İrem Izel

    İrem Izel2 חודשים לפני

    Bruh you can't even find 10 similarities

  63. Angel Pansari

    Angel Pansari2 חודשים לפני

    Oop i had such high hopes knowing about this the first time but now its eh if u dont compare it to winx club i guess it’s better but winx club is honestly better since this is just idk I’m trying not to compare it to winx club

  64. that.girl. Devi

    that.girl. Devi2 חודשים לפני

    I'm new to the show and didn't know about The Winx Club show. The Netflix show was great but looking at the comparisons, its embarrassing that the cartoons were more racially diverse.

  65. Minaminas CTFTLKHTTYDRATLDA&OFan99 2.0

    Minaminas CTFTLKHTTYDRATLDA&OFan99 2.02 חודשים לפני

    Another difference: One is better

  66. Grove-Slayer 64

    Grove-Slayer 642 חודשים לפני

    Moral of the story: do not even try to revive cartoons.

  67. marshmallows

    marshmallows2 חודשים לפני

    “top 10 differences” bitch just say “the whole movie”

  68. Miyanoai14

    Miyanoai142 חודשים לפני

    The saddest thing is this show was actually pretty good. Had they not called it Winx and gave everyone new names, they could have made it an original story. Or at least just say it was loosely based on the show, or maybe even took place in the future when Althea has changed and there was a different cast. Would certainly make sense for the wing evolution.

  69. evilspeedskater91

    evilspeedskater912 חודשים לפני

    I wan't to see it like this. As a winx show. yes i agree with the critics. But if you see it as a reboot stand alone version BASED of the originals made for an older audience. Its a really nice show. I do wright books myself that i hope to share withe the world one day. And from what i have lerned for the past 15 years of wrighting, analysing and evolving in storrytelling. As a stand alown i like it alot. but yes. its nothing like the childe show. and it shuldnt be either. its an adaption for an older people. Good in its own way. And i think that the burned ones got potential. Almost got hte withewalker feeling of them if the aughters makes it right going forward. (sorry for my bad englich but i hope you get my point. not may main language.

  70. shiv

    shiv2 חודשים לפני

    Oof this was... something... critique video on my channel

  71. sonrisa verdean

    sonrisa verdean2 חודשים לפני

    Why’d you ignore Aisha?

  72. Júlia kálmán

    Júlia kálmán2 חודשים לפני

    Wtf ???

  73. NEC_NA

    NEC_NA2 חודשים לפני

    Its so pathetic to see all the hate comments. The producers and the cast did all that during a freaking pandemic and y‘all cry cause it aint all glitter and sparkly 👁👄👁 Its a Netflix teenage drama series. Having the typical good/bad people and obvious story lines (like the cartoon winx had) the show would be canceled after one season lmao

  74. Jupiter logo Usa

    Jupiter logo Usa2 חודשים לפני

    It's so tacky and cheap

  75. Zandisile Khetwayo

    Zandisile Khetwayo2 חודשים לפני

    Any attempts from this show to be femenist is deadass offensive to femenists.

  76. Patrick San Juan

    Patrick San Juan2 חודשים לפני

    Tecna better be in season 2

  77. Mid Night

    Mid Night2 חודשים לפני

    Guys the tv show is not supposed to be the same as the cartoon there some twist and maybe in the future of the tv show it will get better for some of y’all that’s not liking it

  78. Trevor Simons

    Trevor Simons2 חודשים לפני

    In my opinion the cartoon on 4kids and nickelodeon was and still is better than the live action netflix show.

  79. Shiwani Bhardwaj

    Shiwani Bhardwaj2 חודשים לפני

    I miss flora so much!!!! I mean... why???? I am 22 and still have her poster in my bedroom

  80. Manekin89

    Manekin892 חודשים לפני

    Cuz they need a fat girl in show

  81. T i y a

    T i y a2 חודשים לפני

    Why did they make Stella mean??!! Like a spoilt brat in pressure she was like my fav character cuz she was the comedian...

  82. Phillip Walters

    Phillip Walters2 חודשים לפני

    I am not have seen the Netflix's Fate: A Winx Saga, but seeing who is in it makes me say what the ? I mean not having Tecna and Flora and the rest of the specialists in it is just sad. I am hoping that we do see them in the series and I am hoping that the character Beatrice is the Trix fused together under spell and that Valtor is her or their really father

  83. austin eafford

    austin eafford2 חודשים לפני

    The Netfix series, Fate: The Winx Saga which is base of the Winx Club is almost not as perfect as the cartoon version.

  84. Alexis Otti

    Alexis Otti2 חודשים לפני

    Sky is a prince is father name is king something

  85. itz rochester

    itz rochester2 חודשים לפני

    in conclusion: this show is actual hot GARBAGE

  86. GachaLife Girl

    GachaLife Girl2 חודשים לפני

    I wouldn't say it's whitewashing. Maybe the actresses who would've looked more like their counterparts we're not as good in acting. Ever heard of the phrase "cast the one who acts best"?

  87. itz rochester

    itz rochester2 חודשים לפני

    @Manekin89 huh?

  88. Manekin89

    Manekin892 חודשים לפני

    It is also its fatwashing

  89. itz rochester

    itz rochester2 חודשים לפני

    @GachaLife Girl there is a big issue with the lack of representation of poc in media. it would be different if they made someone in a historical or non fiction series who is supposed to be white into a black person because that role relies on the person's race or it is an important factor that impacts the story. but to add a fictional character in an originally majority monoracial (white) environment only adds diversity and representation. take the little mermaid for example. there is literally only ONE black princess ever and SEVEN white ones. a black girl playing ariel doesnt change anything about the plot but it makes things more diverse, potentially for little girls who can see a princess that looks like them which is something i wish i had growing up and only seeing white people on tv in a variety of different roles and only black people in the same recycled (usually unpleasant) stereotypes :)

  90. GachaLife Girl

    GachaLife Girl2 חודשים לפני

    @itz rochester but a black guy for a part that should have been white? I am just saying that it could be like Heimdall in the Thor movies. We don't know the background of the casting. And the casting is a difficult thing. Ildris Alba was the best cast for Heimdall in the MCU. And that is Hollywood so someone more ehtically fitting would have been no problem. Maybe. But Netflix is not Hollywood. And even Hollywood does the "cast who's best"-thing (e.g. Heimdall). Ofc, just as yours, my argument is pure speculation bcs as far as I know, Netflix has still a statement to make. If they will. We don't know what was going on behind the scenes. I just think it's unfair to imediately call white washing without knowong if it really was. So my guess of them casting the best actress is as good as yours with white washing.

  91. itz rochester

    itz rochester2 חודשים לפני

    @GachaLife Girl so ur telling me you couldn't find one asain actress that fit the role. or one latina/hispanic actress who's also plus sized? seems unlikely.

  92. Dinesh kumar

    Dinesh kumar2 חודשים לפני

    Well.... Thinking about it I mean that I think totally think aisha is the powerfulest cause she has water!!!! In a scence when we saw her she made some time of idk but she totally made something which even blocked bloom fire🥰🥰🥰

  93. navi16

    navi162 חודשים לפני

    *Winx Club? more like Riverdale.*

  94. Kaitlyn Marie

    Kaitlyn Marie2 חודשים לפני

    Kinda makes me mad that they didn’t even keen the og names

  95. Kaitlyn Marie

    Kaitlyn Marie2 חודשים לפני

    Plus I don’t like how stella likes sky

  96. Timika Simmons

    Timika Simmons2 חודשים לפני

    I’m glad that this video pointed it out as the number one spot. The animated version had a diverse main female leads cast and the live action didn’t do the same. I pointed out to someone that as a kid, I always thought Musa was of Asian descent, flora was Hispanic, Aisha was black, tecna maybe from Russia Stella and bloom was white. I’m surprised there’s no flora or tecna on this show as well as putting all three characters of the trix into Beatrix.

  97. madie van der ven

    madie van der ven2 חודשים לפני

    I really loved the show but it was really different than the originally Winx club

  98. Zahirah Ahmed

    Zahirah Ahmed2 חודשים לפני

    didnt riven used to date darcy in the first season of the animated series

  99. Cacophonous 11

    Cacophonous 112 חודשים לפני

    So like was Beatrix the “Trix” just combined into one character? 🤔

  100. Maytal Acedo

    Maytal Acedo2 חודשים לפני

    The 3 villains in wind saga was my concern since they r the most iconic girls ever in the series.

  101. Emily Diy

    Emily Diy2 חודשים לפני

    i really want brandon to be in season 2

  102. Yasmin Oliveira

    Yasmin Oliveira2 חודשים לפני

    I don't believe they made a love triangle between Stella bloom end sky. One nice thing about the cartoon was that they never had rivalry over a boy

  103. Hayli Hill

    Hayli Hill2 חודשים לפני

    I think they only made Fate Musa an empath because they thought a music fairy wouldn't be useful. Plus Beatrix's air powers include sound.

  104. Hayli Hill

    Hayli Hill2 חודשים לפני

    What about Ice powers netflix. Fire, Earth, Air, Water, Mind, Ice. Technology.

  105. Eva

    Eva2 חודשים לפני

    I prefer Winx Club ;-;

  106. Michael Anthony

    Michael Anthony2 חודשים לפני

    Am I the only one that remembers Nabu? I think he should make an appearance soon.

  107. Pratistha Kashyap

    Pratistha Kashyap2 חודשים לפני

    To be honest this show really good and every WinX fans want to watch this. But, how this show is not appropriate. They vastly changed things . They made it a adult dark show. And the most saddest thing they literally made bloom and Stella enemy . And deleted Brandon. But seriously this show did a total justice to cartoon. I love it


    Rachel THE NERDY GEEK COLLECTOR2 חודשים לפני

    I love both in the cartoon version Bloom has no clue she's a fairy princess she has to be told by her parents and find out on her own and in the first episode of the live action she knows a fairy

  109. Audrey It Is

    Audrey It Is2 חודשים לפני

    You'd think there would be more technology in the show since the time period should be near ours. And imagine what technology and magic COMBINED could do, like in the og series.

  110. Daniela Pena

    Daniela Pena2 חודשים לפני

    The show itself is pretty great but in our minds it’s bad because it’s supposed to be a remake of the original. Netflix should have either made it a show on its own or remade it correctly.

  111. Christopher Cook

    Christopher Cook2 חודשים לפני

    I’d say Dane has a big role, but idk people are gonna complain regardless, keep in mind there has only been 6 episodes tho

  112. Francis indini Botwey

    Francis indini Botwey2 חודשים לפני

    there were male wizards like nabu and the wizard of the black circle.

  113. Arthi Natarajan

    Arthi Natarajan2 חודשים לפני

    I love winx club the more

  114. YOW shi

    YOW shi2 חודשים לפני

    Im gonna watch the cartoon i already watch the fate winx. I actuallt love it. Even tho many people don't. I like that it doesnt stick to the original of it. And i want season 2.😂